Is Big Data dangerous for our cities?
This article is also available here in Spanish.

Is Big Data dangerous for our cities?

My list

Author | Jaime Ramos

Cities benefit from the countless advantages offered by Big Data traffic management. It forms an essential base for the most promising technological solutions of the century, such as autonomous vehicles or carbon neutral cities. But, is there a dark side to Big data?

IoT: Is Big Data dangerous?

big data 2

Big Brother, Psychohistory, Neuromancer… The science fiction genre is full of tales about the dystopian concept of a remote-controlled reality. The devils surrounding the Big Data dream are based on the same model.

Once we consent to the assignment of personal data, a complex and, above all mysterious journey begins. It may begin as a simple commercial exchange of information. For example, when we take out a service via a platform. We soon find out that the information given is used to send us advertisements for similar services. However, it does not end here.

Is Big Data being used for malicious purposes?

The information accumulated by giants such as Google, Amazon, Alibaba or Facebook are not just stored in their data farms. It falls into the hands of other stakeholders, whose interests are unknown and over which we do not have a direct control.

But, does it really matter if a company or an administration headquartered millions of kilometers away knows the cleaning habits of our robot vacuum cleaner or what type of series we stream? Although it may not seem relevant, it may be crucial depending on how this information is being used and, particularly, as it goes through a collective and not an individual sieve.

What are the risks of data trafficking in smart cities?

Smart cities are often accused of using and abusing data flows. For mobility solutions, urban traffic management, energy rationalization or relationships with IoT to be as successful as they were intended, it is important to consider the consequences of knowing what citizens do in real time or thanks to data warehouses. These are some of the most significant dangers and risks.

Loss of privacy

Privacy is the first right at risk as a result of the wonders of the uncontrolled flow of data. According to Rebecca Herold, CEO of The Privacy Professor, in statements to Csoonline, "it is going to become increasingly difficult to do anything without having an associated identity nexus".

She refers to the fact that, despite the efforts to maintain user anonymity, the processes and standards of countless technologies need to store certain personal data in order for their solutions to make sense. This applies to any device with sensors and which we call smart.

Usage metrics can be collected for aspects such as the use of a municipal application or parking meters without providing data such as the name of the user, but when these data are crossed with their geographic location and habits, it is easy to associate them with the person behind the smart phone or service used. And the more information that is available, the easier it is to reverse the anonymization process.

Discrimination

Analyses of big data flow may include inaccuracies and lead to intentional prejudices. Therefore, systems that use these types of data may carry out discriminatory practices.

This is the case, for example, when more general selection criteria are applied, which end up generating an individual discrimination, not to mention the discriminatory potential if there is an unlawful use behind such processes.

After all, one of the main fears in the urban context is the use of Big Data and AI to make social control instruments more sophisticated. Let’s imagine, for example, a tool to detect traffic offenses in real time, but with criteria differentiating between vehicle types based on their engine size, which is the case in low-emission zones in cities.

Cyberthreats

big data 3

City security goes from the streets to the "cloud". In recent years, we have seen how few are safe. Cyberattacks on cities increased in 2019. In 2020, 104 local administrations were victims of cyberattacks in the United States alone. A phenomenon that also affects smart homes.

Tackling these challenges requires city councils and administrations to get involved in the development of municipal systems, increasing the ethical standards of algorithms or opting for implemented urban infrastructure monitoring systems.

Images | Freepik/fanjianhua, Freepik/DCStudio

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

JB
Jeroen Brink
Municipality Haarlemmermeer
Data advisor engaging with the whole organization to become a more datadriven organization.
DD
Daniel Dan
-
Student in Airlangga University
AV
Alicia Villar
Municipalidad Purranque
LS
Laura Sturk
The Design Wolf
HO
Hyae Cinth Ochotorena
University of Basque Country
Graduate Student
AJ
Alberto Jimenez Gomez
Fractus S.A.
Patent Engineer
JM
Jeff Merritt
World Economic Forum
Head of IoT and Urban Transformation
MS
Marionela Simova
Cluster Sofia Knowledge City
Cluster coordinator
JR
Jeshua Roig
Universidad Nacional de Ingenieria
Researcher
LV
Linda van den Borne
ITEA Office
PR&Communications specialist
AS
agostina spataro
escuela
NK
Najmeh Kardanian
Fava
Smart city department manager of shiraz municipality
BR
Bru Recolons
Impulsa Talentum Fundation
President founder
GT
Giorgos Tsapparellas
Liverpool John Moores University
Researcher
LC
leonardo carvalho
Editora Poliedro
coordinator
HS
Hannah Milena Seichter
Bergische Universität Wuppertal
AH
Atif Hasan
Patkais Private Limited
Managing Director
PG
PRAMOD GURJAR
TATVAM AUTOMATION | CONSULTING
DECISION MAKER
AJ
Afnan Ahmed Junaidi
Parsons Corporation
PR
Paras Rathour
Paras Business center
Compani is working hard