failed smart city
This article is also available here in Spanish.

Why do some smart cities fail?

My list

Author | Jaime Ramos

Why do many smart cities fail to take off? We have associated smart cities with a combination of almost Utopian promises of wellbeing. What obstacles stop us from reaching the established expectations?

What is considered a successful smart city or a failed project?

Measuring the success of a smart city is not a simple task. On the whole, we have inherited a series of tools from the sciences of demography and sociology that help us to establish parameters that go beyond borders.

Smart cities considered to have failed share a drop in per capita income, in the price of housing and, ultimately, in the population itself. The first parameter is a classic clue regarding the average degree of social wellbeing; the second constitutes a warning of economic decline and that the abandonment seen in the third is likely to occur.

The fundamental mission of smart cities is to encourage the opposite route via numerous instruments. In doing so, the educational arena acts as a particular glue and lubricant that connects social and economic dynamics.

The dream of a smart city that never happened

smart cities fail 2

The problem is that many of the instruments that give smart cities an identity can be considered double-edged swords. That is, beyond the aforementioned parameters, the success of a smart city tends to be confused with the actual technological means that seek that ideal.

Smart cities that never take off tend to elevate their ambitions through mistaken approaches, like those they follow.

Errors when identifying challenges and problems

Detroit or Manchester are normally cited as major  examples of urban cities that were unable to identify the immediate social and economic challenges and insisted on models that ended up leading to their industrial decline.

Ordos, China’s ghost city, is a modern example of how the advantages of a macro-smart city project can end up being a fiasco as a result of mistakes made at the time of determining local requirements. Today, only around 100,000 people live there, very different from the million people it should have housed according to the targets of an initiative that cost $200 billion dollars in 2001.

Immature technology

The promises and expectations generated are also cut short as a result of embracing incomplete technological solutions. The investment and efforts required by technologies such as autonomous driving or urban air mobility, entail risks related to innovations that still have years of development before them.

Imperfect technologies that jeopardize, discriminate or pollute

smart cities fail 3

The most perverse side of technological advancements in cities stems constitutes the ideal premise of any science fiction author. There are countless examples, such as CCTV surveillance systems in public places, Big Data and Artificial Intelligence that promise greater security and administrative efficiency and end up as repressive or discriminatory instruments; monetized technologies to generate class privileges or technological solutions that increase the energy and sustainability issue.

A study by Lux Research that appeared in Forbes highlighted the supply problems due to the inability to deliver millions of batteries that power the sensors associated with Big Data, not to mention the harmful emissions in the production of that energy.

Another example analyzed in numerous forums is the Rio de Janeiro and IBM partnership. The agreement led to the development of a series of software products for smart cities, which increased the gap between more and less privileged citizens.

Lack of urban leadership

smart cities fail 4

Given these distortions, it is essential to achieve a balance between policies that support the public strategies of what intend to be considered smart cities (particularly, in interferences of private interests). This is nothing new.

The Canadian researcher, Jane Jacobs already hinted at it in 1961 in her book ‘The Death and Life of Great American Cities’: "private investment shapes cities, but social ideas (and laws) shape private investment. First comes the idea of what we want, then, the mechanism must be adapted to achieve that image".

Images | Freepik/wirestock, Freepik/rawpixel.com, Freepik/jcomp, Freepik/onlyyouqj

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

AB
Agam Bhatnagar
EDII, Ahmedabad
SS
sam shen
Smart City Promotion Team, Taipei Computer Association
Head of Southeast Asian Region
CG
Christian García
Partido Político de México
Coodinación del área de tecnología de información de el partido politico mexicano.
GO
Gabriela Orquera
MDMQ
Técnica de Planificación
LG
Luis Manuel Garcia Castillo
Metropolitan Planning Institute of Tijuana
FA
Forastier Ana
Engel & Völkers
GS
Geovanni Siem
Universidad Central de Venezuela
RA
Rashed Alhamdan
Gulf Skills
AP
AmirMohammad Parvini
Municipality of Kermanshah
International Affairs Manager
HG
HUGO GÓMEZ
Arquitectura Contemporánea
CEO
MM
Mari Carmen Molina Rubio
Biblioteca Singuerlín
Tècnica aulixliar de biblioteca
JB
J.Ignasi Bonet
CTTI
Strategic consultant at Secretary of Digita Policies.
PF
pipin firdaus
Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia
IT Staff
MA
Marta Almela Salvador
City Council of Sant Feliu de Llobregat / Peakway
Project Manager
YM
Yannick Müller
CityLAB Berlin / Technologiestiftung Berlin
PN
plinio neira
adminsitracion municipal rioengro
TN
Takehiko Narumi
Smart City Institute Japan
Executive Director
VO
Vojko Obersnel
City of Rijeka
Executiv activities in municipality
ID
Iman Doroudi
Tehran Municipality
Programing and planing
AE
Ana Esnarriaga
Oitta

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.