electric car
This article is also available here in Spanish.

It is not all benefits: five unforeseen problems of transport electrification

My list

Author | Jaime Ramos

Electric cars are here to stay, and particularly in cities. There is a global consensus regarding this maxim of our times. However, with the continued expansion of electric mobility, numerous unforeseen issues have arisen that have not been taken into account until now.

They are common in areas of the world that lead the way in electrification, such as Norway; or major cities that have fostered the electric vehicle transition. Below are some of the problems that have emerged as a result of the success of electric vehicles.

1. Careful with flooding

The battery technology in electric vehicles is very safe. What was not taken into account was what would happen in the event of certain disasters such as hurricanes, specifically, and salt water flooding. In Florida, after 21 electric vehicles spontaneously combusted as a result of this in 2022, measures have been taken this year asking drivers to shelter them from storms and coastal areas during these climate episodes.

2. Chinese electric vehicle graveyards

We are not referring to battery recycling, but rather to the vast number of new models abandoned by Chinese companies that tried to succeed in this emerging market and failed. In fact, the country went from having 500 electric vehicle manufacturers in 2019 to around 100 in 2023. The images from outside Hangzhou are depressing from a smart city perspective, with thousands and thousands of vehicles waiting to be recycled.

3. Crowded bus lanes

The success of electric vehicles in Norway have taught us numerous lessons. To incentivize the purchase of electric vehicles, drivers were allowed to use bus lanes. Years later, in 2015, they had to rectify this measure, first in Oslo, and then in the rest of the country, as a result of traffic jams and complaints from bus drivers.

4. From worrying about autonomy to worrying about charging

This is, perhaps, the most significant unforeseen issue with electric vehicles in cities. Sales are on the rise, but the public charging infrastructure is still lacking and this has led to numerous scenarios. For example, in countless cities many tenants who choose to rent and have an electric vehicle, find that they have nowhere to charge it. In the United States, they are trying to tackle this issue with the right-to-charge laws.

Another emerging phenomenon which, while not so dramatic, is equally curious, is the demand for fast charging stations seen in some areas of Norway. The mass use of electric vehicles is such that, even some fast charging points cannot cope with the demand and the associated queues.

5. They threaten some fundamental principles of smart cities

All that glitters is not gold with electric vehicles. Although the value of electrification in the journey towards decarbonization and sustainability goals is undeniable, this journey is affecting other priorities. In recent years, for example, there have been cases of injustice due to an imbalance in subsidies or access to low emission zones.

Another conflictive matter is related to the occupation of urban spaces. Planners and defenders of more humanized urban models, such as the Canadian Jason Slaughter, remind us that the solution for traffic in cities is not simply changing all fossil fuel vehicles for electric vehicles. After all, as he indicates, electric cars "are still a horrendously inefficient way to move people around, especially in crowded cities".

Images | Freepik/freepik

Related Content

Recommended profiles for you

DG
David Guerra
Alfa Energy
CEO
MI
Marc Iglesias
AMB
Head of section
KQ
Krisna Qris
Balikpapan Creaticity Forum
Founder and Tribe leader
SR
SANJAY KUMAR RATH
PRAYAGRAJ SMART CITY LIMITED
CF
Camilo Fernández
Metro Linea 1
AO
Alex O'Mara
University of Sydney
HD
Hardie Davis Jr
The SkyBridge Firm
SC
Salvador Carbó
Nexus Geographics
Business manager. Logistics, Insurance, Real State solutions
CM
Cláudio Matos
Ideias Dinamicas
Developer
JA
Jaume Aragay Badia
Obrador Digital
TL
THIAGO LARANGEIRA
Codex
FC
Fabienne Chanavat
Chanavat Consulting
WP
Wasu Phokaew
TTD
Electrical Engineer
FC
Fabienne Chanavat
Chanavat Consulting
SG
Simon Goffin
HelloApp
CEO
HV
HORACIO VARELA
CONSULTOR
SF
SALAKO Farid
City of Sèmè-Podji
FP
Francesc Pi
Veepee
Supply Chain Director
FF
Fausto Fanin
ZF Group
HS
Hendra Septianto
Iipex
T141

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.