Green roofs: advantages and disadvantages of rooftop gardens
This article is also available here in Spanish.

Green roofs: advantages and disadvantages of rooftop gardens

My list

Author | Eduardo Bravo

Rooftop gardens have become increasingly popular in urban centers in recent years. This system does not mean simply installing plants in individual and removable pots, but rather a permanent facility, made with plant elements designed to form part of the building’s structure.

FIRA-AZOTEAS-SOSTENIBLES-ENG

Types of green roofs

There are also different types of green roofs depending on the vegetation used and whether they are physically accessible. Therefore, green roofs may be classified as:

  • Extensive: an eco-roof covered with a lightweight, thin layer of vegetation, low-maintenance and non-accessible.
  • Semi-intensive: these create an ornamental green space using plants that require more care and more soil depth that those above, however, on the other hand, people can access them.
  • Intensive: rooftop gardens that accept all types of plant species, including trees. People can access them, but they do require a solid structure to bear the weight of vegetation and people.

green-roofs-23

Benefits of green roofs

Apart from their ornamental effect, rooftop gardens have beneficial effects on the environment and health of people. For example:

Air purification

The photosynthesis process carried out by the rooftop plants absorbs carbon dioxide and releases oxygen, while capturing dust and reducing pollution.

Ambient noise reduction

Green roof substrates tend to neutralize low-frequency sounds, while the plants block high frequency sounds. This means a roof with twelve centimeters of vegetation can reduce noise by forty decibels, and can reduce it by fifty decibels if it has a width of more than twenty centimeters.

green-roofs-24

Temperature regulation

Rooftop gardens help to moderate the ambient temperature thanks to the ability of plants to evaporate water. Furthermore, as it is not a reflective material like glass, granite, marble, stone and other floor coverings, it cools the outside of buildings and, consequently, reduces the surrounding temperature.

Increased biodiversity

Green roofs attract birds, insects and other animals and help to increase biodiversity.

Improved emotional health

Green roofs have a natural appearance and go from being aesthetically hostile elements to attractive gardens. This has a positive effect on the mood of residents who, given the characteristics or location of their properties, are not normally able to see green areas.

green-roofs-25

Disadvantages of green roofs

Despite the undeniable benefits, there are also some disadvantages to green roofs that should be taken into account before installing them.

Maintenance costs

Compared with conventional roofs, they entail greater costs both in their execution and maintenance.

Increased weight on the structure

Not all buildings are suitable for these systems, given the extra weight on top of the structure.

Water filtration due to rainwater retention

The installation of green roofs requires specialist professionals who know exactly how to design the space, together withthe irrigation and drainage systems. It then requires a good design to prevent, among others, the accumulation of rainwater under the structure that could lead to damp and filtrations.

Images | tinseling, erdenebayar, Free-Photos

Related content

Recommended profiles for you

MA
Massimo Albarello
Omnia Network
IV
Inna Vedernykova
Freelance
JG
Jon Gustafson
Stantec
Senior Principal, US East Geospatial Services Leader
JS
Jordi Serrat Padrós
La salle campus Barcelona
Student of the 1st year degree in management of business and technology
ZZ
Zafar Iqbal Zafar Zafar
Capital Development Authority
I am an Urban Planner having BSc, MSc in CRP. Posted as Director Master Planning in CDA, Islamabad.
ON
Oren Nachshon
Tel Aviv Municipality
GIS Manager
IN
Isamu Nishi
NIKKEN SEKKEI
IK
Insan Akhlaqul Karim
Magelang Municipality
AT
ANDRI TSIOUTI
UPC
IK
Islam Kamel
Department of Municipalities and Transport
FP
Figuieres Pascal
NXO
RAS
TV
tuana vural
-
student
MG
María Constanza García
GRUPO SEMANA
Director Semana Educacion
TS
Tarang Sukhatme
Aarvee Associates
Deputy General Manager
KN
Katarzyna Nurzyńska
WSP Poland/ Warsaw University of Technology
FR
Fredrick Royan
Frost & Sullivan
AA
ANA ABRAHIM
Fundação Municipal de Cultura, Turismo e Eventos
Director of Cultural Policies
JS
Juan Carlos Sánchez Tappan
STUDIO OF ARCHITECTURE RESEARCH, SOFAR
Principal
TJ
Tim Jaudszims
TINY SPACE (Tiny Life UG)
GH
Gregory Haley
Henning Larsen
Associate Principal / North American Urbanism Lead

Are we building the cities we really need?

Explore Cartography of Our Urban Future —a bold rethink of ‘smart’ cities and what we must change by 2030.