Proprietary or open-source software? Arguments in favor and against
My list

Author | Eduardo Bravo

Big data and the internet of things are two of the key tools for smart cities to function correctly. The former is used to analyze the abundant data related to citizens, which will subsequently determine the municipal policies and the latter is used, for example, for the management of specific services through mobile devices, such as urban lighting. In both cases, IT systems are required to develop them.

These systems must also follow the principles that inspire these smart cities, including transparency and the control by citizens over the public authorities. This is why some governments are favoring the adoption of free and open-source software.

Differences between open-source and proprietary software

It is common for the differentiation between open-source and proprietary software to focus exclusively on the financial aspect. Proprietary software tends to require a payment in order to be used, and open-source software usually doesn't. However, open-source does not always mean free of charge. In fact, there are open-source software programs that may be sold and generate income for their original creators just like any proprietary software.

Likewise, we may also come across proprietary programs distributed totally free of charge.

Therefore, the relevant difference between the two is the philosophy behind each model. In the case of open-source software, users defend that anybody can have access to the source code, not just to know its architecture, but also to modify it. This enables programs and applications to be improved through the collaborative work of selfless programmers, whose aim is not to obtain financial gain but rather benefits for society as a whole.

open-source-software-27

Proprietary software, on the other hand, is closed-source software and can only be modified by its creators. It tends to have a “security through obscurity” approach, since nobody except its creators can see or modify its source code and only they can add new functions.

Brazil, a pioneer of open-source software in the administration

In 2003, the Brazilian government was the first in the world to massively apply open-source software in the public administration. This initiative was soon established as a mandate, making its use compulsory in government agencies. The reasons behind this decision were the fact that they considered the software to be a common asset and that the IT industry at the time in Brazil was generating more than three billion dollars a year, a third of which was going to the United States for proprietary software licenses.

With these measures, apart from reducing the costs of IT services, the State was encouraging the development of local companies such as the Rio do Grande, which used the Linux system in ATMs of the state-owned Rio do Grande do Sul bank and in the administration’s offices.

The result of this initiative has been greater investment in tailor-made systems for the administration using open source software and a firm emphasis on innovation. However, Brazil’s adventure with open source software has also encountered some stumbling blocks.

In 2016, the country purchased a large number of Microsoft licenses, which, in practice, meant undoing all that had been achieved. Why?__ The development and sometimes the use of open-source software requires specialist providers and professionals__ or, at least, those with certain skills that were not available in the public administration, therefore, the country had to turn to commercial proprietary solutions with technical support that can only be provided by one of the major companies in the industry.

Advantages and disadvantages of open-source and proprietary software

open-source-software-28

In Europe, the European Commission promoted the use of open-source software through plans such as eEurope 2002. However, the application has not been uniform due to the lack of involvement of countries and because the difficulty in migrating from a proprietary software system to a open source one varies depending on whether it is a state, regional or local Administration.

Despite this, there have been plenty of cases in which the change of model has been forced by the attitude of the companies that own the payment programs. At the end of 2002, for example, the city of Munich was informed by Microsoft that it would no longer provide technical support for the local administration’s operating system. Forced to look for an alternative, the authorities chose Linux/Open Office. Since then, the city has returned to Microsoft products and once again to free software, proving that the adoption of open-source programs, although desirable, is not always easy.

Open-source software, after all, also has its disadvantages. Although some distributions of Linux and certain programs have major companies behind them capable of providing solid support, most free software programs depend on the technical support and expertise of the community of users, forcing administrations to work hard on the development of the same. This is particularly critical when the programs in question work with personal data, for example.

Lastly, it is important to remember that both software models operate in a free market and that administrations can choose one or the other guided, simply, by economic criteria. That is what happened in Newham, a district in the metropolitan area of London which, when it found itself in a similar situation to that of Munich, reached an agreement with Microsoft, making it cheaper to continue working with Bill Gates’ company than to use free software. Because, sometimes, proprietary software can be economically competitive.

Images | DragonImages/iStock, lya Pavlov, alexx-ego

Related content
What is digital infrastructure and examples of its application
What is digital infrastructure and examples of its application
Governing the twin transition: Transforming today’s challenges into future opportunities
Governing the twin transition: Transforming today’s challenges into future opportunities
AI & CITIES
AI & CITIES
Proprietary or open-source software? Arguments in favor and against
Proprietary or open-source software? Arguments in favor and against
What are the three main goals of database lifecycle management (DLM)?
What are the three main goals of database lifecycle management (DLM)?
Governments in digital transformation: five areas of action
Governments in digital transformation: five areas of action
What is a smart factory and how will it impact industry?
What is a smart factory and how will it impact industry?
How digitalization is transforming government in emerging economies
How digitalization is transforming government in emerging economies
Medical apps for patients: how can they improve public health?
Medical apps for patients: how can they improve public health?
Velodyne, NavVis and Qualcomm Technologies Working Together to Build Smart Cities Faster
Velodyne, NavVis and Qualcomm Technologies Working Together to Build Smart Cities Faster
In battle with U.S., China to focus on 7 ‘frontier’ technologies from chips to brain-computer fusion
In battle with U.S., China to focus on 7 ‘frontier’ technologies from chips to brain-computer fusion
How can cities help visually impaired people?
How can cities help visually impaired people?
Vintage technology: 'It sounds so much cleaner'
Vintage technology: 'It sounds so much cleaner'
Designers in Tech: How Architecture Is Unlocking the Potential of New Emerging Technologies
Designers in Tech: How Architecture Is Unlocking the Potential of New Emerging Technologies
Treat Smart City Tech like Sewers, or Better
Treat Smart City Tech like Sewers, or Better
Emerging technologies can foster an inclusive COVID-19 recovery
Emerging technologies can foster an inclusive COVID-19 recovery
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Shopping with delivery robots arrives in cities
Technology for smart cities: the pillars of urban planning of the future
Technology for smart cities: the pillars of urban planning of the future
Making Data Center Smart: How Artificial Intelligence Helps?
Making Data Center Smart: How Artificial Intelligence Helps?
Experts Say the ‘New Normal’ in 2025 Will Be Far More Tech-Driven, Presenting More Big Challenges
Experts Say the ‘New Normal’ in 2025 Will Be Far More Tech-Driven, Presenting More Big Challenges
Prof Shafi Ahmed: ‘Technology will completely transform healthcare’
Prof Shafi Ahmed: ‘Technology will completely transform healthcare’
Does the use of Big Data cause privacy concerns?
Does the use of Big Data cause privacy concerns?
Eye tracking technology: what is it and how will we see it in our cities
Eye tracking technology: what is it and how will we see it in our cities
Five top tips for businesses in 2021 from industry experts
Five top tips for businesses in 2021 from industry experts
Brief history of artificial intelligence
Brief history of artificial intelligence
China’s country-as-platform strategy for global influence
China’s country-as-platform strategy for global influence
As Robots Fill the Workplace, They Must Learn to Get Along
As Robots Fill the Workplace, They Must Learn to Get Along
Top 7 IoT Smart City Trends to Look Out In 2021
Top 7 IoT Smart City Trends to Look Out In 2021
“Liquid” machine-learning system adapts to changing conditions
“Liquid” machine-learning system adapts to changing conditions
Can Artificial Intelligence Replicate the Mystery of Human Conversation?
Can Artificial Intelligence Replicate the Mystery of Human Conversation?
China to become world's largest IoT market in 2024: report
China to become world's largest IoT market in 2024: report
The skills Deloitte looks for when it acquires IT service providers
The skills Deloitte looks for when it acquires IT service providers
Who needs a teacher? Artificial intelligence designs lesson plans for itself
Who needs a teacher? Artificial intelligence designs lesson plans for itself
4 Impactful Technologies From the Gartner Emerging Technologies and Trends Impact Radar for 2021
4 Impactful Technologies From the Gartner Emerging Technologies and Trends Impact Radar for 2021
Are Videogames the Future of Remote Work?
Are Videogames the Future of Remote Work?
China to become world's largest IoT market in 2024, says report
China to become world's largest IoT market in 2024, says report
Let interoperability be the foundation of smart cities
Let interoperability be the foundation of smart cities
Four emerging technology trends in 2021
Four emerging technology trends in 2021
Top 10 innovative regions in China
Top 10 innovative regions in China
What does Integration of Artificial Intelligence and Advanced Analytics mean in Business?
What does Integration of Artificial Intelligence and Advanced Analytics mean in Business?
Robots, wristbands, and apps: startups that innovated their products for COVID-induced med tech
Robots, wristbands, and apps: startups that innovated their products for COVID-induced med tech
Top 5 IoT programming languages in 2021
Top 5 IoT programming languages in 2021
How the pandemic will shape the workplace trends of 2021
How the pandemic will shape the workplace trends of 2021
How exactly are smart cities built? From facial recognition and 5G networks to cheap sensors — these are the essential components
How exactly are smart cities built? From facial recognition and 5G networks to cheap sensors — these are the essential components
Cyberplanning: Securing the IoT ecosystem
Cyberplanning: Securing the IoT ecosystem
Stand ready for the big five technology convulsions reshaping markets
Stand ready for the big five technology convulsions reshaping markets
3 ways the pandemic is transforming tech spending
3 ways the pandemic is transforming tech spending
8 Smart Cities to Watch in 2020
8 Smart Cities to Watch in 2020
Microsoft: Smart Places and Infrastructure with IoT, AI, and Digital Twins
Microsoft: Smart Places and Infrastructure with IoT, AI, and Digital Twins
Digital transformation is already revolutionising public healthcare as provided by regions
Digital transformation is already revolutionising public healthcare as provided by regions
Recommended profiles for you
Remember to activate your profile to network!
Activate profile
RK
Rizwan Khan
Ather Technologies
CEO
JG
Juan Pedro Gallardo
Altran
BDM
Tea Mijač
Tea Mijač
FEBT
Teaching & Research Assistant
TP
Trevor Pereira
Voxxeltek
CEO
MG
Michael Girel
AuxBridge
CEO
Palma Piedrahita Seifert
Palma Piedrahita Seifert
PalmapSeifert
CEO - Founder
Khusnul AIDIL Santosa AIDIL
Khusnul AIDIL Santosa AIDIL
Lyt Technology
CEO
Pierluigi De Felice
Pierluigi De Felice
OCTAR TECHNOLOGIES sarls
Marketing Manager
HS
Helen Sweeney
Seagate Technology
Program manager
CZ
Carlos Zúñiga A.
Telecom Consulting Services
Senior Consultant
tt
test-evento-start-02 test-evento-start-02
start.cat
ee
EM
Ezequiel Merino Cabrera
AIS Technology
Videocomunication dept.
Jan Bradley Jan
Jan Bradley Jan
City of Calgary
Director
Paras Rathour
Paras Rathour
Paras Business center
Compani is working hard
IR
Iñigo Robredo
BilbaoTIK - Ayuntamiento de Bilbao
Smart data manager
SO
Scott Ong
Axis Communications
Solutions, Systems and Services
Debora Bessa
Debora Bessa
Artek | espacios que comunican
Business Lead Partner
EM
Elayaraja M
PSG
Teaching assistant
JH
Jess Hale
BCP council
Volunteer
AT
Akihiro Tsuji
Tokyo Electron Miyagi Limited
Senior Specialist

Only accessible for registered users
This content is available only for registered users
TO: $$toName$$
SUBJECT: Message from $$fromName$$